Skip to content

Homes For Sale In Old Mill Basin

Old Mill Basin

Experience the timeless charm of Old Mill Basin, where history seamlessly blends with modern comfort. Indulge in the tranquility of tree-lined streets and established neighborhoods. Treat your taste buds with an array of culinary delights at various eateries serving classic comfort food and diverse flavors, all amidst the classic architecture and well-maintained homes that give Old Mill Basin its unique character.

Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $696K
Lowest Price $194K
Highest Price $1.4M
Total Listings 33
Avg. Days on Market 70
Avg. Price/SQFT $484

Property Types
(active listings)

Homes For Sale in Old Mill Basin

Sort by:
Click to view all photos

$259,000

1722 East 55th Street 35F, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 850 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 490037
1489 East 55th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

$675,000

1489 East 55th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 1 BATHS 1,016 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492579
Click to view all photos

$689,000

5503 Avenue M, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 952 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492456

$699,000

4910 Avenue M, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,840 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 492411
Click to view all photos

$748,000

1453 East 65th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,242 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492339
Click to view all photos

$799,000

5508 Avenue O, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,980 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492266
Click to view all photos

$699,000

1462 East 65th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 1 BATHS 1,368 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 492202
Click to view all photos

$229,000

1774 East 54th Street 13B, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 800 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 492171
Click to view all photos

$839,000

1578 East 51st Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,309 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 491112
Click to view all photos

$240,000

1199 East 53rd Street 5C, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 750 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 491005
Click to view all photos

$1,138,000

2070 East 55th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

5 BEDS 2,536 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 490945
Click to view all photos

$280,000

2042 East 57th Street 98A, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 800 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 490773

$729,000

5703 Avenue O, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

2 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,570 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 490723
Click to view all photos

$785,000

1352 East 66th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,288 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 490534
Click to view all photos

$1,375,000

2070 Pearson Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

7 BEDS 5 BATHS 3,696 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 490446

$500,000

1669 East 49th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,012 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 490315
Click to view all photos

$989,000

1671 East 52nd Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,248 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 490287
Click to view all photos

$1,100,000

1556 East 56th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,328 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 490277
Click to view all photos

$679,000

1554 East 58th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 820 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 489974
Click to view all photos

$759,000

1489 East 54th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

4 BEDS 3 BATHS 945 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 489944
Click to view all photos

$1,350,000

1701 East 48th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,056 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 489900
Click to view all photos

$279,000

5318 Fillmore Avenue 9F, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 850 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 489428
Click to view all photos

$799,000

1438 East 51st Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 2 BATHS 2,118 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 489245
Click to view all photos

$229,999

1270 East 51st Street 6H, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 750 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 488994

$250,000

1270 East 51st Street 3N, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 900 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 488954
Click to view all photos

$399,000

2051 East 57th Street 101G, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 1 BATHS 1,200 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 488816
Click to view all photos

$265,000

5318 Fillmore Avenue 9D, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

2 BEDS 1 BATHS 850 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 488775

$594,000

1466 East 56th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

5 BEDS 2 BATHS 924 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 488551
Click to view all photos

$698,000

1799 East 52nd Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

2 BEDS 2 BATHS 1,476 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 488170
1563 East 46th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

$820,000

1563 East 46th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,788 BUILDING SQFT Single Family MLS ® # 486423

$899,000

5515 Avenue K, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

3 BATHS Multi-Family MLS ® # 484632
Click to view all photos

$220,000

2049 East 58th Street 139A, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 800 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 481550
Click to view all photos

$180,000

1777 East 54th Street 22A, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

1 BEDS 1 BATHS 700 BUILDING SQFT Coop MLS ® # 487580
Click to view all photos

$1,018,000

2075 East 55th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

7 BEDS 5 BATHS 2,688 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 487342
Click to view all photos

$1,019,000

2069 East 55th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

7 BEDS 5 BATHS 3,088 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 487341

$1,015,000

2009 East 55th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

7 BEDS 5 BATHS 2,688 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 487340

$999,999

4415 Avenue M, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

5 BEDS 3 BATHS 1,896 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 485378

$749,000

1708 East 54th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11234

7 BEDS 4 BATHS 2,300 BUILDING SQFT Multi-Family MLS ® # 483763

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you’re in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search

Latest Listings

67 Roff Street, Staten Island, NY, 10304

$628,000

67 Roff Street, Staten Island, NY, 10304
MLS#: 2501949
Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.
15 Mann Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$899,000

15 Mann Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2502284
Robert DeFalco Realty, Inc.
5 Clifford Graves Court, Red Bank, NJ, 07701

$2,200,000

5 Clifford Graves Court, Red Bank, NJ, 07701
MLS#: 22404954
50 Forest Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527

$619,000

50 Forest Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527
MLS#: 22508610
213 Julius Street, Iselin, NJ, 08830

$510,000

213 Julius Street, Iselin, NJ, 08830
MLS#: 2509809R

$754,000

165 West End Avenue 16H, New York, New York, 10023
MLS#: 488159
14 Strathmore Way, East Windsor, NJ, 08520

$640,000

14 Strathmore Way, East Windsor, NJ, 08520
MLS#: 22510502
16 Saint Kitts Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$399,000

16 Saint Kitts Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22507749
1900 E 51st Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11234

$799,900

1900 E 51st Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11234
MLS#: 2501503
380 Port Royal Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$250,000

380 Port Royal Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 2510652R
505 Jarrard Street, Piscataway, NJ, 08854

$875,000

505 Jarrard Street, Piscataway, NJ, 08854
MLS#: 2510298R
17 Parkview Loop, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$629,900

17 Parkview Loop, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2501216
52 Amador Street, Staten Island, NY, 10303

$1,099,999

52 Amador Street, Staten Island, NY, 10303
MLS#: 2501024
61 Snug Harbor Avenue, Highlands, NJ, 07732

$475,000

61 Snug Harbor Avenue, Highlands, NJ, 07732
MLS#: 22508762
33 Ludwig Lane, Staten Island, NY, 10303

$499,999

33 Ludwig Lane, Staten Island, NY, 10303
MLS#: 2502200
18 Back Bone Hill Road, Millstone, NJ, 08510

$739,900

18 Back Bone Hill Road, Millstone, NJ, 08510
MLS#: 2511280R
5 Llewellyn Place, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901

$575,000

5 Llewellyn Place, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901
MLS#: 2511107R
61 Sunset Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$889,000

61 Sunset Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2501038
1205 Jeffrey Street, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712

$700,000

1205 Jeffrey Street, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712
MLS#: 22511032
411 Ridgecrest Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312

$749,000

411 Ridgecrest Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312
MLS#: 2501956
110 Lovelace Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312

$1,175,000

110 Lovelace Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312
MLS#: 2405065
72-74 sabo Street, Carteret, NJ, 07008

$899,999

72-74 sabo Street, Carteret, NJ, 07008
MLS#: 2508021R
23 Hazelhurst Street, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901

$213,900

23 Hazelhurst Street, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901
MLS#: 2408512R
235 Radnor Avenue, Pine Beach, NJ, 08741

$515,000

235 Radnor Avenue, Pine Beach, NJ, 08741
MLS#: 22511090
167 Union Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10303

$599,999

167 Union Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10303
MLS#: 2501707
158 Mill Road, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$599,000

158 Mill Road, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2501371
230 Weed Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$438,000

230 Weed Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2500917
12 Idlewild Road, Edison, NJ, 08817

$989,000

12 Idlewild Road, Edison, NJ, 08817
MLS#: 2560820M
409 Birch Street, Bayville, NJ, 08721

$460,000

409 Birch Street, Bayville, NJ, 08721
MLS#: 22508181
106 Mohican Lane, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087

$285,000

106 Mohican Lane, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087
MLS#: 22503200
186 Brahma Avenue, Bridgewater, NJ, 08807

$419,900

186 Brahma Avenue, Bridgewater, NJ, 08807
MLS#: 2511229R
127 Bradley Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$749,999

127 Bradley Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2501558
2 White Pine Road, South Brunswick, NJ, 08831

$997,000

2 White Pine Road, South Brunswick, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2214083R
126 Cassidy Place H2, Staten Island, NY, 10301

$419,000

126 Cassidy Place H2, Staten Island, NY, 10301
MLS#: 2404681
44 Finley Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$899,000

44 Finley Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2500192
70 John F Kennedy Boulevard, Pine Beach, NJ, 08741

$350,000

70 John F Kennedy Boulevard, Pine Beach, NJ, 08741
MLS#: 22510213
1 Truman Drive, Marlboro, NJ, 07746

$929,999

1 Truman Drive, Marlboro, NJ, 07746
MLS#: 22510612
78 Lake Avenue, Ocean Grove, NJ, 07756

$1,450,000

78 Lake Avenue, Ocean Grove, NJ, 07756
MLS#: 22505134
106 Woodland Road, Piscataway, NJ, 08854

$415,000

106 Woodland Road, Piscataway, NJ, 08854
MLS#: 2510587R
117 Milton Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$859,000

117 Milton Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2500340
1403 Kingsley Street 209, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712

$792,790

1403 Kingsley Street 209, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712
MLS#: 22509031
501 Connecticut Road, Browns Mills, NJ, 08015

$239,900

501 Connecticut Road, Browns Mills, NJ, 08015
MLS#: 22508303
70 Woodchuck Parkway, Whiting, NJ, 08759

$75,000

70 Woodchuck Parkway, Whiting, NJ, 08759
MLS#: 22510403
119 Huntington Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527

$549,900

119 Huntington Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527
MLS#: 22509095
23 Griggs Road, Cranbury, NJ, 08512

$799,000

23 Griggs Road, Cranbury, NJ, 08512
MLS#: 2561174M
604 Greenwood Avenue, Old Bridge, NJ, 08879

$435,000

604 Greenwood Avenue, Old Bridge, NJ, 08879
MLS#: 2561055M
2140 Knapp Street 4G, Brooklyn, New York, 11229

$239,000

2140 Knapp Street 4G, Brooklyn, New York, 11229
MLS#: 488096
1536 Bath Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, 11228

$1,800,000

1536 Bath Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, 11228
MLS#: 486981
120 13th Avenue, Seaside Park, NJ, 08752

$899,900

120 13th Avenue, Seaside Park, NJ, 08752
MLS#: 22510706
6 Claridge Drive, Middletown, NJ, 07748

$600,000

6 Claridge Drive, Middletown, NJ, 07748
MLS#: 22510820
31 Carlisle Road, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$279,000

31 Carlisle Road, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22503957
228 Palombi Court, East Brunswick, NJ, 08816

$385,000

228 Palombi Court, East Brunswick, NJ, 08816
MLS#: 2511737R
64 Whitman Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10308

$800,000

64 Whitman Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10308
MLS#: 2501827
74 Steele Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306

$790,000

74 Steele Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
MLS#: 2501465
15 Toby Terrace, Monroe, NJ, 08831

$939,900

15 Toby Terrace, Monroe, NJ, 08831
MLS#: 2510048R
73 Ashland Avenue, East Orange, NJ, 07017

$630,000

73 Ashland Avenue, East Orange, NJ, 07017
MLS#: 2561061M
13 Windsor Place, Brooklyn, NY, 11215

$2,999,999

13 Windsor Place, Brooklyn, NY, 11215
MLS#: 2500271
780 Barlow Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312

$589,900

780 Barlow Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312
MLS#: 2500110
657 AMBOY Avenue, Edison, NJ, 08837

$685,000

657 AMBOY Avenue, Edison, NJ, 08837
MLS#: 2512393R
42 Country Drive, Staten Island, NY, 10314

$558,888

42 Country Drive, Staten Island, NY, 10314
MLS#: 2502071
13 Wynwood Drive, South Brunswick, NJ, 08852

$329,000

13 Wynwood Drive, South Brunswick, NJ, 08852
MLS#: 2511026R
6 Jennifer Court, Piscataway, NJ, 08854

$1,150,000

6 Jennifer Court, Piscataway, NJ, 08854
MLS#: 2561042M
16 Holsman Road, Staten Island, NY, 10301

$980,000

16 Holsman Road, Staten Island, NY, 10301
MLS#: 2500683
1346 East 99th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11236

$760,000

1346 East 99th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11236
MLS#: 478834
47 Regal Walk, Staten Island, NY, 10303

$525,000

47 Regal Walk, Staten Island, NY, 10303
MLS#: 2500140
330 Randolph Road, Freehold, NJ, 07728

$1,375,000

330 Randolph Road, Freehold, NJ, 07728
MLS#: 22508000
1301 Wellington Place, Aberdeen, NJ, 07747

$370,000

1301 Wellington Place, Aberdeen, NJ, 07747
MLS#: 22511244
65 Jackson Avenue, Carteret, NJ, 07008

$539,900

65 Jackson Avenue, Carteret, NJ, 07008
MLS#: 2510719R
28 Wallace Street, East Brunswick, NJ, 08816

$425,000

28 Wallace Street, East Brunswick, NJ, 08816
MLS#: 2510283R
244 Slater Boulevard, Staten Island, NY, 10305

$699,000

244 Slater Boulevard, Staten Island, NY, 10305
MLS#: 2500589
3 Willoughby Court, Toms River, NJ, 08757

$299,000

3 Willoughby Court, Toms River, NJ, 08757
MLS#: 22428569
85 Seattle Slew Drive, Howell, NJ, 07731

$225,000

85 Seattle Slew Drive, Howell, NJ, 07731
MLS#: 22507972
1825 Monitor Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08753

$600,000

1825 Monitor Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08753
MLS#: 22514359
26 Standish Drive, Howell, NJ, 07731

$489,000

26 Standish Drive, Howell, NJ, 07731
MLS#: 22514353
1291 Coulter Street, Toms River, NJ, 08755

$595,000

1291 Coulter Street, Toms River, NJ, 08755
MLS#: 22514360
450 Freemont Avenue, Bayville, NJ, 08721

$740,000

450 Freemont Avenue, Bayville, NJ, 08721
MLS#: 22514344
5 Chadwick Court, Waretown, NJ, 08758

$700,000

5 Chadwick Court, Waretown, NJ, 08758
MLS#: 22514351
211 Long Swamp Road, New Egypt, NJ, 08533

$599,900

211 Long Swamp Road, New Egypt, NJ, 08533
MLS#: 22514354
19 Stanley Lane, Middletown, NJ, 07748

$929,000

19 Stanley Lane, Middletown, NJ, 07748
MLS#: 22514361
115 Lexington Court, Holmdel, NJ, 07733

$489,000

115 Lexington Court, Holmdel, NJ, 07733
MLS#: 22514346
52 Watkins Road, Brick, NJ, 08724

$384,900

52 Watkins Road, Brick, NJ, 08724
MLS#: 22514347
4 Augusta Drive, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087

$497,896

4 Augusta Drive, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087
MLS#: 22513797
2465 Woodland Road, Manchester, NJ, 08759

$499,000

2465 Woodland Road, Manchester, NJ, 08759
MLS#: 22514356
1447 Thornwood Drive, Mount Laurel, NJ, 08054

$295,000

1447 Thornwood Drive, Mount Laurel, NJ, 08054
MLS#: 22503303
(718) 987-7900