Butler Manor Real Estate Statistics
Average Price | $1.8M |
---|---|
Lowest Price | $499K |
Highest Price | $3.4M |
Total Listings | 7 |
Avg. Days on Market | 135 |
Avg. Price/SQFT | $448 |
Property Types
(active listings)
Homes for Sale In Butler Manor
$1
9536 Schenck Street 3, Brooklyn, New York, 11236
$5,700
24 Albert, Red Bank, NJ, 07701

$29,900
176 Mockingbird Way, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$30,000
53 Marcia Memorial Circle, Jackson, NJ, 08527
$32,500
30 Kingfisher Way, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$34,000
1 Panda Lane, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$39,900
162C Columbine Avenue, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$39,900
5 Parrot Court, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$45,000
1 Eagle Drive, Whiting, NJ, 08759

$49,000
11 Pigeon Court, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$49,000
28 C Hancock Drive, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$49,500
6 D Hancock Drive, Whiting, NJ, 08759
About Butler Manor
Butler Manor is a distinguished Staten Island neighborhood, and it traces its origins back to Elmer Butler, a prominent maritime and shipping magnate. Initially developed around the grant Butler Manor house in 1908, the area has evolved into a modern community with quite a few elegant oceanfront properties, and some more accessible detached homes. Residents of Butler Manor know how truly special this area is, and if you’re in the market for waterfront properties, this should be on your list.
Residents of Butler Manor also have great access to natural and historical amenities. The nearby Conference House is a significant site from the Revolutionary War – it anchors a 267-acre state park offering extensive recreational activities. From hiking trails and a children’s playground to a waterfront pavilion, this park is absolutely a central feature of the community, providing residents with opportunities to outdoors and explore some of the local history of the area.
Butler Manor Homes For Sale
Butler Manor offers a decent selection of housing options. As mentioned above, the neighborhood is mostly known for its stunning waterfront properties with incredible views of the water. These homes range from expansive, custom-built residences to more modest yet still stunning detached homes – if you’re interested in building something from the ground up, you’ll also find the occasional lot of land for sale, as well.
The architectural styles in Butler Manor vary, with many homes reflecting a more modern aesthetic while you can still find some homes that pay homage to the area’s historical roots. The community’s quiet streets and well-maintained properties make it one of Staten Island’s premier residential areas. Whether you’re after a stately home with historical significance or something a bit more contemporary with relatively easy access to the water, you can certainly find what you’re after in Butler Manor.
Be the first to know when new properties in Butler Manor become available. Register with us for free to get exclusive access to new listings and receive notifications when new homes hit the market!
Butler Manor Entertainment and Amenities
Residents of Butler Manor also have great access to entertainment options in and around the area. For shopping and dining, the nearby Veterans Road Strip is home to a variety of stores and restaurants. Here, you’ll find everything from the popular Joe & Pat’s Pizzeria to a Target store, providing something with local flavor but still having access to everything you need. Additionally, the Bricktown Center at Charleston offers a more comprehensive shopping experience with major retailers like Home Depot and Regal Cinemas.
Those who love the outdoors also can find the Clay Pit Ponds State Park Preserve just a short drive away, offering hiking, bird-watching, and educational programs about the area’s natural development. Golfers can enjoy a round at the South Shore Golf Course. For water sports enthusiasts, the Great Kills Harbor offers boating and fishing opportunities, making it easy to enjoy a day on the water. In short – you’ll never be at a loss for things to do if you decide you want to buy a property in Butler Manor.
Education Near Butler Manor
Education is quite important within the Butler Manor community. Tottenville High School is known for its great academic programs, and most high-school aged children in this area go to that school. I.S. 34 also offers comprehensive educational opportunities for younger students.
For families who prefer private education, Our Lady Help of Christians is a historical institution, has served the community since 1904. The school is committed to providing a nurturing educational environment rooted in Christian values. Additionally, nearby elementary schools like P.S. 6 and P.S. 1 offer strong foundational education in welcoming settings – this ensures high-quality education for children in Butler Manor.
Butler Manor FAQ
Q: How walkable in Butler Manor for residents?
A: Despite its peaceful, suburban feel within Butler Manor, most errands are typically going to require a car. The area is not highly walkable due to its residential layout with larger properties and limited sidewalks on some streets.
Q: What public transportation options are available near Butler Manor?
A: Butler Manor is serviced by several bus routes that connect to key points on Staten Island, including the S55 and S56 which provide access to the Staten Island Railway at the Huguenot Station. This makes access to the other parts of the borough and into Manhattan relatively easy.
Q: What are the healthcare facilities like near Butler Manor?
A: Residents of Butler Manor have access to a range of healthcare services. Staten Island University Hospital’s South location is a short drive away – this will provide residents with the majority of their healthcare needs, including emergency care.
Staten Island Neighborhoods
Annadale, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Arden Heights, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Arlington, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Arrochar, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Bay Terrace, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Bloomfield, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Bulls Head, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Butler Manor, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Castleton Corners, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Charleston, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Clifton, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Clove Lake, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Concord, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Below the Boulevard, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Dongan Hills Colony, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Elm Park, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Eltingville, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Emerson Hill, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Emerson Valley, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Graniteville, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Grant City, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Grasmere, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Great Kills, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Grymes Hill, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Heartland Village, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
High Rock, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Huguenot, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Latourette, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Lighthouse Hill, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Livingston, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Lower Todt Hill, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Manor Heights, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Mariners Harbor, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Meiers Corners, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Midland Beach, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
New Brighton, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
New Dorp, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
New Dorp Beach, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
New Dorp Heights, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
New Springville, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Oakwood, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Old Town, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Park Hill Real Estate, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Pleasant Plains, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Port Richmond, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Prince’s Bay, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Randall Manor, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Richmond Valley, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Richmondtown, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Rosebank, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Rossville, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
S.E. Annadale, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Shore Acres, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Silver Lake, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Snug Harbor, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
South Beach, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
St. George, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Stapleton, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Sunnyside, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Sunset Hill, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Todt Hill, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Tompkinsville, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Tottenville, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Travis, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Ward Hill, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
West Brighton, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Westerleigh, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Willowbrook, Staten Island, NY Homes for sale in
Woodrow, Staten Island, NY

Start searching for your dream home now.
When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you’re in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.
Latest Listings

$628,000
67 Roff Street, Staten Island, NY, 10304
$899,000
15 Mann Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
$2,200,000
5 Clifford Graves Court, Red Bank, NJ, 07701
$619,000
50 Forest Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527
$510,000
213 Julius Street, Iselin, NJ, 08830
$754,000
165 West End Avenue 16H, New York, New York, 10023
$640,000
14 Strathmore Way, East Windsor, NJ, 08520
$399,000
16 Saint Kitts Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757
$799,900
1900 E 51st Street, Brooklyn, NY, 11234
$250,000
380 Port Royal Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08757
$875,000
505 Jarrard Street, Piscataway, NJ, 08854
$629,900
17 Parkview Loop, Staten Island, NY, 10314
$1,099,999
52 Amador Street, Staten Island, NY, 10303
$475,000
61 Snug Harbor Avenue, Highlands, NJ, 07732
$499,999
33 Ludwig Lane, Staten Island, NY, 10303
$739,900
18 Back Bone Hill Road, Millstone, NJ, 08510
$575,000
5 Llewellyn Place, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901
$889,000
61 Sunset Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
$700,000
1205 Jeffrey Street, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712
$749,000
411 Ridgecrest Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312
$1,175,000
110 Lovelace Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312
$899,999
72-74 sabo Street, Carteret, NJ, 07008
$213,900
23 Hazelhurst Street, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901
$515,000
235 Radnor Avenue, Pine Beach, NJ, 08741
$599,999
167 Union Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10303
$599,000
158 Mill Road, Staten Island, NY, 10306
$438,000
230 Weed Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
$989,000
12 Idlewild Road, Edison, NJ, 08817
$460,000
409 Birch Street, Bayville, NJ, 08721
$285,000
106 Mohican Lane, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087
$419,900
186 Brahma Avenue, Bridgewater, NJ, 08807
$749,999
127 Bradley Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10314
$997,000
2 White Pine Road, South Brunswick, NJ, 08831
$419,000
126 Cassidy Place H2, Staten Island, NY, 10301
$899,000
44 Finley Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
$350,000
70 John F Kennedy Boulevard, Pine Beach, NJ, 08741
$929,999
1 Truman Drive, Marlboro, NJ, 07746
$1,450,000
78 Lake Avenue, Ocean Grove, NJ, 07756
$415,000
106 Woodland Road, Piscataway, NJ, 08854
$859,000
117 Milton Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
$792,790
1403 Kingsley Street 209, Asbury Park, NJ, 07712
$239,900
501 Connecticut Road, Browns Mills, NJ, 08015
$75,000
70 Woodchuck Parkway, Whiting, NJ, 08759
$549,900
119 Huntington Drive, Jackson, NJ, 08527
$799,000
23 Griggs Road, Cranbury, NJ, 08512
$435,000
604 Greenwood Avenue, Old Bridge, NJ, 08879
$239,000
2140 Knapp Street 4G, Brooklyn, New York, 11229
$1,800,000
1536 Bath Avenue, Brooklyn, New York, 11228
$899,900
120 13th Avenue, Seaside Park, NJ, 08752
$600,000
6 Claridge Drive, Middletown, NJ, 07748
$279,000
31 Carlisle Road, Toms River, NJ, 08757
$385,000
228 Palombi Court, East Brunswick, NJ, 08816
$800,000
64 Whitman Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10308
$790,000
74 Steele Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10306
$939,900
15 Toby Terrace, Monroe, NJ, 08831
$630,000
73 Ashland Avenue, East Orange, NJ, 07017
$2,999,999
13 Windsor Place, Brooklyn, NY, 11215
$589,900
780 Barlow Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10312
$685,000
657 AMBOY Avenue, Edison, NJ, 08837
$558,888
42 Country Drive, Staten Island, NY, 10314
$329,000
13 Wynwood Drive, South Brunswick, NJ, 08852
$1,150,000
6 Jennifer Court, Piscataway, NJ, 08854
$980,000
16 Holsman Road, Staten Island, NY, 10301
$760,000
1346 East 99th Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11236
$525,000
47 Regal Walk, Staten Island, NY, 10303
$1,375,000
330 Randolph Road, Freehold, NJ, 07728
$370,000
1301 Wellington Place, Aberdeen, NJ, 07747
$539,900
65 Jackson Avenue, Carteret, NJ, 07008
$425,000
28 Wallace Street, East Brunswick, NJ, 08816
$699,000
244 Slater Boulevard, Staten Island, NY, 10305
$299,000
3 Willoughby Court, Toms River, NJ, 08757
$225,000
85 Seattle Slew Drive, Howell, NJ, 07731
$600,000
1825 Monitor Drive, Toms River, NJ, 08753
$489,000
26 Standish Drive, Howell, NJ, 07731
$595,000
1291 Coulter Street, Toms River, NJ, 08755
$740,000
450 Freemont Avenue, Bayville, NJ, 08721
$700,000
5 Chadwick Court, Waretown, NJ, 08758
$599,900
211 Long Swamp Road, New Egypt, NJ, 08533
$929,000
19 Stanley Lane, Middletown, NJ, 07748
$489,000
115 Lexington Court, Holmdel, NJ, 07733
$384,900
52 Watkins Road, Brick, NJ, 08724
$497,896
4 Augusta Drive, Little Egg Harbor, NJ, 08087
$499,000
2465 Woodland Road, Manchester, NJ, 08759